Rosewood :Fiction & Fact
--------------------------------------------------
The Rosewood incident began January 1st, 1923, and eventually culminated with the burning of the small predominantly Negro town six days later. And though the Rosewood riots were unquestionably racially motivated, it should also be noted that these types of incidents were very rare in American history. Between 1900 and 1964, there were only 31 (at least, that's all I could find >>
Link). And of those 31 ... 77% were a direct consequence of - provoked by - either a sexual assault or a murder (usually a police officer).
Note: There was no "massacre" in any of the two Rosewood riots.
Archived newspaper article supporting this version...
LINK
----------------------------
Now let’s get to the 1923 Rosewood Riots: Fiction & Fact
Fiction: The town of Rosewood (Florida) in 1923 was an entirely Negro town and boasted a population of about 300 or more.
Fact: Rosewood was described as “mostly African-American”, therefore, there were some Americans living in the community. In the book The Chronological History of the Negro, a far left-leaning, pro-integration recounting of African-American experiences from the 1700s and up until 1968, tells us there were “six buildings” burned down in the town (the town had just recently been vacated due to news of impending mob violence). And after the buildings were burned, then, a few days later, “the 12 remaining structures” were burned. These 12 structures were obviously residences (homes) in the African-American part of the small community. Doing the simple math here, it tells us that most likely there were only 12 African-American families in Rosewood. The typical African-American family back then would have consisted of about six or seven. That would put the African-American population of Rosewood at approximately 80, with the adult male population at around 12 to 14.
Note: Despite Wikipedia's claim (produced from a thoroughly unreliable source, African-American Maxine Jones) that Sumner and Rosewood had a combined population of "344 blacks and 294 whites," I could find no existing census data to support this claim. Rosewood shared a census tract with Sumner, so there is no way of knowing exactly how many people (white or black) lived in Rosewood. However, the "12 structures", or homes, in the black section give a pretty accurate clue. Whites were likely about half or less of the black population in Rosewood, so the white population would be about 30 or 40 (6 or 7 families) ... and the total Rosewood population (white & black) would be around 120.
Of further note: I'm assuming that the white mob only burned the black homes. However, all reports of the Rosewood riots state that the town was destroyed. So it could also be that the 12 structures were the total of homes in Rosewood. So, using that as the number of homes, of course, the size of the population of Rosewood would be radically reduced. For example, if one were to assume eight of the structures belonged to African-American, and the remaining four were occupied by Americans, that would put the approximate size of the black population at around 50, with about 7 or 8 adult black males; the white population would be around 35. The total Rosewood population in this scenario would be about 85 people. I'm also assuming (no way to find the actual number) that all 12 structures were occupied by families on January 1st.
Archived newspaper account of what happened. LINK
------
Fiction: From Wikipedia: South Florida had imposed legal racial segregation under Jim Crow laws, requiring separate black and white public facilities and transportation.[6] Blacks and whites created their own community centers: in 1920, the residents of Rosewood were mostly self-sufficient. They had three churches, a school, a large Masonic Hall, a turpentine mill, a sugarcane mill, a baseball team named the Rosewood Stars, and two general stores, one of which was white-owned.
Fact: "Jim Crow laws" : South Florida, as well as the entire country, was actually operating under Plessy v. Ferguson (1896 Supreme Court decision allowing for the separation of the races). One distinct people living separate from another distinct people was the established norm in America at that time. It was also the established norm throughout human history. Blacks were a free people, free to build their own towns, their own cities and their own industries; or colonize a place in the vast expanse of unsettled land in America (e.g., like the Mormons). Regarding the buildings in Rosewood, this has already been covered. There were "six buildings" burned. The quote above indicates there were nine structures in Rosewood that were not homes. The existing structures in Rosewood at that time were: two churches (white and black); two schools (white and black); a likely abandoned turpentine mill; and only one daily operating business in Rosewood, which was the general store operated by a white male (John Wright).
------
Fiction: The railroad stopped in Rosewood.
Fact: The railroad did not have a regularly scheduled stop in Rosewood in 1923. And why would it? The only industry in the area, the timber industry, had moved more than two decades earlier to Sumner. There was also no hotel and no business activity (one general store) in Rosewood..
------
Fiction: All the African-Americans who formerly lived in Rosewood had remained silent about the incident over all these years (1923 to 1982) because they decided that it was just such a terrible event ... they would all just blot it out from their memories.
Fact: When the news of impending mob violence reached Rosewood, all African Americans fled the small town, with the exception of Mrs. Carrier , a couple young kids (actual number unknown) and the African-American fugitive (Jesse Hunter). Since Mrs. Carrier and the fugitive died in a hail of gunfire from the posse, and the kids were too young to recall what happened, there were no other African-Americans left in the tiny town as eyewitnesses to report on the incident.
------
Fiction: An American female, Mrs. Fannie Taylor, was in fact attacked and beaten up... but made up a story about an African-American male doing it. Why? Because the brutal attack was really perpetrated by her “white” male lover (i.e. she was having an affair) and she knew she would have to explain the bruises to her husband when he arrived home from work. Hence, the “made-up story”.
Fact :
1.) On the day of the home invasion / assault, an African-American male, Jesse Hunter, had escaped from a prison work detail in the vicinity of Rosewood. The fugitive would have been penniless and, naturally, in need of money to get out of the Rosewood area. Strong-arming a young American female home alone would be an obvious source to obtain some quick money.
2.) The source for the story of the alleged “white guy” seen coming out of Fannie Taylor's home came from an African-American Arnett Doctor. He wasn't alive at the time of the Rosewood incident. He told a white male journalist, Gary Moore, that his mom, Philomena Goins, who would have been 7 years old at the time of the incident, told him all about how she and her mother, Sarah Carrier, witnessed the white lover leaving Mrs. Taylor's premises on the day of the assault. Note: Gary Moore and Arnett Doctor's "new" version to Rosewood was created in 1982.
Reality check... The new version of the Rosewood incident has Fannie Taylor beaten up by her "white lover," then he flees toward Rosewood (about 3 miles away). Here are the only two possible scenarios - that I can think of - where Fannie Taylor would run to the sheriff and report an erroneous assault on her by a black man.
Scenario 1: After the beating by her white lover, Fannie Taylor looks in the mirror and notices bruises she knows she cannot explain to her husband, so she and the white male cook up a story where she intends to frantically run to the sheriff and tell him a black man beat her and robbed her. Well, if this is the scenario, then why is the white male fleeing? He has nothing to worry about. He knows Fannie is blaming a black man. Right? Hmmm. Maybe the white male walked the three miles to Rosewood. Possible.
Scenario 2: The white male strikes Fannie Taylor. Furious, Fannie Taylor tells her white lover she's going to the sheriff and report him, then storms out of the house. However, along the way, Fannie decides against blaming the assault on her white lover and instead hurriedly concocts a story about a black man beating her. Again, though, why would the white male be fleeing for his life? He has nothing to really fear. There were no domestic violence laws back then, so a female being struck by a male in a lover's quarrel would not be an arrestable offense. Also, the white male, one could logically expect, would quickly figure out that if Fannie Taylor did report her beating to the sheriff, this would reveal to everyone, including her husband, that she is having an affair! And what would that mean in 1923? Scandal! Divorce! Ostracizing! So under this scenario as well, one would expect the white male lover to flee. But it certainly would have been time for him to leave her premises. Again, maybe he walked toward Rosewood.
Both of the above scenarios, in my opinion, are actually equally implausible. In fact, no scenario can be created to provide a logical reason for the white male to flee for his life toward Rosewood. The only plausible scenario as to who beat up Fannie Taylor is the original version: An escaped convict, Jesse Hunter, invaded Fannie Taylor's home, beat her up (possible rape) , made her reveal where any household money was, then he fled toward Rosewood. And one final thing to consider: When Gary Moore heard this fantastic new version to Rosewood from Arnett Doctor, who, again, was claiming he was reciting what his mother told him about the event, why didn't Gary Moore go straight to the source i.e. the mother? WHY?? Read below:
" [Philomena Goins] Doctor called her family members [after Arnett Doctor and Gary Moore's new version of Rosewood was published in 1982] and declared Moore's story and Ed Bradley's television exposé were full of lies."
wikipedia
The alleged affair in the new version is simply not to be believed.
------
Fiction: Six African-Americans, perhaps many more, were murdered; many being lynched. Also, sadistic white people would cut off the body parts of the blacks and take them home for souvenirs.
Fact: Four African-Americans died, two adult males and two adult females: Sam Carter; Mrs. Sarah Carrier; Jesse Hunter; Miss Lexie Gordon. There were no lynchings (hangings) in these "riots", which occurred over the following two days. None of the four blacks were dismembered for souvenir body parts.
Day 1, Jan.1st : A couple of hours after the assault, an American posse with bloodhounds tracked a scent from Fannie Taylor's home to a home in Sumner, which belonged to an African-American male, Sam Carter. This piece of information (which is beyond dispute) is of vital importance. Where did the bloodhounds get the scent they tracked to Mr. Carter’s home? They got that scent from the clothes of Fannie Taylor that the African-American male left on it when he physically assaulted her. The bloodhounds, able to track a human scent up to 36 hours after it was left, had no trouble tracking the scent to Mr. Carter’s place (no, these dogs were not bred by white people to be racists toward blacks). At Mr. Carter's home is where the scent stopped. The group of armed Americans, therefore, had no other conclusion to draw than Mr. Carter had met with and aided the fugitive to escape by wagon. A rope was tied around Mr. Carter's neck and he was threatened with being hanged if he didn’t reveal what he knew. However, Mr. Carter remained uncooperative and, much to the consternation of the mob, an American (unknown ) shot and killed him with a single gunshot to the body (or head). Mr. Carter was left where he fell and the mob moved on (Mr. Carter was NOT hanged).
From the official coroner's jury inquest, 1923:
"We the Jury after the examination of the said Sam Carter who being found lying Dead, find that the said Sam Carter came to his Death by being shot by Unknown Party so say we all."(1)
Day 2, Jan 4th : In the evening hours, hearing rumors that the African-American fugitive was at a house in Rosewood, a small group of armed Americans (no way of knowing how many) descended on the home of Mrs. Sarah Carrier (an African-American). Two American males went to the front door and knocked loudly, demanding that everyone inside come out. NOTE: This is where the known evidence of what follows ends. What did happen here, however, is really the most important aspect related to the burning of the African-American homes in Rosewood. The two white males who knocked on the Carrier front door were fact gunned down. And it was this incident that set the stage for the torching of Rosewood.
Most Likely scenario: At the home of Sarah Carrier, two Americans, Henry Andrews, 42, and C. P. "Poly" Wilkerson, 45, knocked on the front door and demanded that everyone inside come out. The fugitive, Jesse Hunter, is inside and likely holding a gun on Sarah Carrier (And how did Jesse Hunter get to the Carrier's home? There's only one way he could have got there: Sam Carter [gunned down three days earlier] took him there by wagon to hide him). When Sarah Carrier opened the door the Negro fugitive ambushed the two Americans, murdering them at point-blank range. Gunfire immediately erupted from the posse and Mrs. Carrier was killed in a hail of bullets. The fugitive was also mortally wounded; however, he still returned fire. After a period of time, the posse members, running low or out of ammunition, and also not sure if the fugitive was actually dead, decided to leave and return the next day. Upon returning the following day the two dead Americans are claimed. Inside the Carrier home are two dead bodies: Sarah Carrier and an adult Negro male.
Note: There is no known source that has positively identified the adult African-American male found dead in the Carrier home. The 'new version' of this event claims that the victim is Sylvester Carrier (son of Sarah Carrier). Naturally, this would create a scenario where Mr. Carrier is simply defending his house and avenging the senseless slaughter of his mother by sadistic and bloodthirsty white guys. However, a few questions arise with this version: Why would members of the posse gun down Sarah Carrier for no reason, and a woman some of the posse members were likely acquainted with? Why would Sylvester Carrier gun down two white males on his front porch that he likely knew for years? Why would Sylvester Carrier risk the lives of his mother and the children in the house ... by provoking a gunfight with a posse? In my opinion, the new version - that Sylvester Carrier was defending his house - just doesn't seem logical. The only logical version that does fit is that the rumor was true that the fugitive was inside the Carrier home ... and he (Jesse Hunter) slaughtered the two Americans.
Day 3, Jan. 5th. : A large group of Americans (no way of knowing how many) set fire to six buildings in the Negro section of Rosewood. These were not homes. No person (white or black) was killed or injured in this incident.
Day 4, Jan. 7th : To avenge the slaughter of the two white males, white people from nearby towns gathered in Rosewood and burned the remaining 12 structures - specifically the 12 African-American homes. An African-American female, who was apparently suffering from typhoid fever and was bedridden, was burned alive, or escaped the house but died of smoke inhalation, when her house was set afire. Most likely, the ones setting the fire were not aware she was inside.
Note: Wikipedia's version states that a black male was “shot in the face” and then “hung…”. This alleged incident first appears after 1982 in the “new version' of Rosewood, which was manufactured by Gary Moore, a white male “self-employed” (unemployed?) freelance writer.
------
Fiction: One African-American is known to have been forced to dig is own grave before he was killed. Another African-American male, Mingo Williams, minding his own business and doing some hunting, was gunned down when he was spotted by some white males who were driving to Rosewood (Jan.7th).
Fact: The African-American male being forced to dig his own grave was said to be James Carrier. The newspaper account of this incident tells us that James Carrier was shot days after Rosewood was burned. Americans most likely blamed him - one would assume on provable evidence - that he was directly or indirectly involved in the shooting deaths of the two American posse members. There is also NO existing credible evidence - that I can find - that a group of Americans gunned down an African-American male who was out hunting.
------
So let’s sum up what we have as to the true and ironclad facts concerning Rosewood :
1. An American female was attacked and beaten up by an African-American male. There is nothing I can find in the way of credible evidence that states the female was raped. However, there is evidence that states that members of the posse hunting for the African-American fugitive believed the woman was raped.
2. All credible evidence points to the perpetrator of the attack on Fannie Taylor being an African-American male who had just escaped from a nearby prison work crew (Jesse Hunter).
3. According to the book Chronological History of the Negro (published in 1969), and whose sources were newspaper accounts from the Rosewood riots period, stated "four Negroes and two white people were killed." Only ONE African-American male (Mr. Sam Carter) is known to have been deliberately shot and killed by someone who was certainly an American (white). Three more African-Americans, Mrs. Sarah Carrier, fugitive Jesse Hunter, and Miss Lexie Gordon, were also killed. Sarah Carrier and Jesse Hunter died in the Carrier home from a hail of gunfire from the posse ... after two American posse members were massacred - ambushed. The other African-American, a female, Lexie Gordon, stricken with typhoid fever and bedridden, died by fire or smoke inhalation when her home was set afire.
4. Because an African-American gunned down two Americans, this caused a fury among the local American population, and they took out their rage against the physical structures belonging to African-Americans in Rosewood: six buildings were burned, then, a few days later, 12 African-American homes were burned.
5. Mr. Sylvester Carrier, whose mother died inside their home, presumably in a hail of gunfire after the killing of the two Americans, according to Arnett Doctor, Mr. Carrier was still alive after the Rosewood incident. Arnett Doctor claims his family received Christmas cards from Sylvester many years after the incident.
>>>> Proof that Sylvester Carrier was NOT defending his house against white males trying to break his door down: "Arnett Doctor [son of Philomena Goins Doctor - whose grandmother was Mrs. Carrier and killed by the posse], in his interview for the report given to the Florida Board of Regents, claimed that his mother received Christmas cards from Sylvester Carrier until 1964" <<<< Ergo, Sylvester Carrier was alive and well after the Rosewood incident. In other words, he was not the black male lying dead in the house with his mother.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosewood_massacre (notes)
So, who was the dead African-American male on the floor with Sarah Carrier? It had to be the African-American fugitive Jesse Hunter.
6. Two other deaths allegedly related to the Rosewood burning were added after 1984 - likely so those surviving family members could cash in on any settlement that was in the works.
7. The new version to the Rosewood incident was created in 1982 by a freelance reporter, (white male) Gary Moore. Moore relied on Arnet Doctor as his only source. Arnett was the son of Philomena Goins Doctor, who was 7-years-old at the time of the Rosewood incident. Arnett claimed that his mother told him all about the Rosewood incident. However, Arnett’s mother accused him of lying.
" [Philomena Goins] Doctor called her family members [after watching 60 Minutes recreate Arnet Doctor and Gary Moore's 'new version' of Rosewood] and declared Moore's story and Ed Bradley's television exposé were full of lies." wikipedia
------
1. http://afgen.com/roswood
